~Coffee Cake Cookies!

Once again I present to you a sweet treat born out of weakness and dedicated to my selfishness!  I’m not saying that I blame my parents, but ..errr, eh, hmmm!  ;)

I was raised in a household that lovingly produced multiple generations of Coffee Cake lovers.  Piles of crumbly, sweet, Streusel  would tease & tempt me as it sat atop a slab of hard, dry, dusty “cake”.  That was the ending to almost every family dinner.  It was made very clear to all of us kids, that picking off that prized topping was punishable by death, or at the very least, some harsh public embarrassment of being yelled at in front of the entire family to not “ruin the cake for everyone!”

…can you say issues?!  LOL!

At the tender age of 6, it became my life’s goal (not really..lol) to someday let loose and rip that Cake to shreds, eating only the soft, buttery, cinnamony topping…having my way with it, all without getting in trouble!  :)

Sooo, I came up with a way to enjoy all of that great Coffee Cake topping, while still maintaining a pretense of manners!  EVERY bite of these melt-in-your-mouth cookies deliver that classic Coffee Cake greatness, minus the awkward “picking off the top” sneaky & illegal maneuver of my childhood!  Take that Mom!  ;)

What you’ll need:

1 Roll of Pillsbury Sugar Cookie Dough

CRUMBLE:

1/2 cup packed light brown sugar

1/2 cup all-purpose flour

1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon

4 tbsp. unsalted butter..softened

BROWN SUGAR GLAZE:

1/2 cup packed light brown sugar

1/2 tsp. vanilla extract

2 tbsp. water

Directions:

In a med. bowl combine the 1/2 cup Brown Sugar, 1/2 cup of Flour, 1/2 tsp. Cinnamon and 4 tbsp. soft Butter  mix well with a fork until it’s a sand-like texture, set aside…

Bake the Cookies according to the package directions, taking them out of the oven 5 minutes before they’re done.  Gently press the back of a spoon into the cookie, creating a small dent…

Top the cookies with some of the Crumble and finish baking them until they’re golden brown…

While they’re finishing up in the oven, prepare the Glaze by mixing 1/2 cup light brown sugar with 1/2 tsp. Vanilla and 2 tbsp. water.  Top the warm cookies with some Glaze…

Let them cool before you touch them~ Ahh, don’t touch yet…

Drizzle those cookies with the glaze, and don’t be shy…

Take note at their irresistible beauty…

Dust them with a virgin layer of Powdered Sugar if you so desire..

I highly recommend it, at least on some…

Serve yourself up a well-deserved portion…

Grab a cup of hot Coffee, dig in and enjoy Adulthood!  :)

60 Responses to ~Coffee Cake Cookies!

  1. You always come up with the best combinations of recipes! I would have never in a million years thought to combine coffee cake and cookies, but they look absolutely delicious. I might need to break my healthy eating rule for a day to try this recipe out. :)

  2. Jo and Sue says:

    Oh. My. Goodness. You are a super genius! I cannot wait to try these. Thank you for sharing your recipe :)

  3. Audrey says:

    I cant take it, heading to the store to purchase the items i need to make these!

  4. Beth says:

    These look amazing and yet simple to make. We love coffee cake (especially the crumb topping), and sugar cookies too…..what a delight these are going to be. Now, how many will I need to bake just to last thru the night after husband and stepson get home? :) LOL

  5. CHristal Zam says:

    OMG i dont know if its because im pregnant or i just have a big sweet tooth but this is going on my top five list. Nothing can beat a coffee cake cookie. My family loved it and im pretty sure I have become addicted as well :) . Great recipe

  6. Cheri Fettes says:

    I LOVE the way you think.

  7. Shirley Bell says:

    wish I could just print the recipe off, without umpteen pages of pictures step by step just to get the recipe!

  8. Rousha says:

    How do I receive your recipes in my email?

  9. Louise says:

    These look so yummy!!!

    Only thing I would add is some chopped roasted pecans (only because I think most everything needs nuts or pecans).

  10. Dolores says:

    The recipe says “Top the cookies with some of the Crumble and finish baking them until they’re golden brown”…does that mean some one each. If not, what do I do with the rest of the crumble.

  11. Barb says:

    ohhhhh I agree..some nuts added……can’t wait to bake….it’s 8:30 pm here think I’ll wait till am (if I can LOL)

  12. liz says:

    Think I’ll try these when I’m feeling better

  13. Shirley Darnell says:

    like your page but would like it more if could print a shorter form of the recipe. waste too much paper and ink.

    • Amy says:

      Simply delete each section you don’t want. You can delete pics and/or un-needed text, each section has a delete option as you hover your cursor over it! ~Hope that helps! :)

  14. Betty says:

    I just made these cookies and they are good. But I didn’t have to roll of sugar cookies so I used Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie mix in a bag, 1 lb 1.5 oz bag. And I got 24 cookies out of it. Some were quite big. I will be making them again. But it will be a double batch.

  15. Tamra says:

    I’m not a baker so I don’t know the difference…. how important is it to use unsalted butter? I have all the ingredients in my frig except that and was hoping to use regular stick of butter.

  16. Julie R says:

    Wow! I knew these would be heaven and they certainly are! Thank you so much for the recipe. My family and friends thank you too!

  17. Sue says:

    Making these today for a Super Bowl party.

  18. I think i screwed something up. The crumble topping is like cookie dough. my glaze is runny like a thin syrup. The cookies are also so thin once i baked them. Maybe I am just no “Suzy HomeMaker :(

  19. Amanda says:

    I so cant wait to make these. The crumble topping is always my favorite part of anything. But I am going to try it with a snickerdoodle recipe! We will see…!

  20. Suz says:

    I made these cookies. Left off the glaze & got rave reviews from my family. I will be making these again. Suz

  21. kirsten says:

    Made these for my family for Superbowl! HUGE hit! Thanks for the recipe!!

  22. Kanden says:

    These look absolutely delish! I wanna try them ASAP. Though I have a quick question: if you were to use 2 rolls of the sugar cookies, would you have to double the batch of the crumble and glaze?

    • Amy says:

      Hmm..I like lots of crumble so I’d at least make up a little more for 2 rolls of cookie dough, but if you don’t like too much, you may be able to stretch it! :)

  23. [...] they are DELICIOUS! First attempt at the recipe and it turned out perfect! very easy to follow this recipie Just put these in the oven! I love that [...]

  24. [...] and baked. I finished the 3rd Game of Thrones book and made Daddy’s Cookies and these delish Coffee Cake Cookies. I don’t think I’ve mentioned Daddy’s cookies before. My sister and I made these [...]

  25. Whitney says:

    You are a genius. These are amazing! Thank you.

  26. Krista says:

    I am going to make these for Easter but would like to make ahead of time (probably the day before). Do they store well? and what’s the best way to store them? Thanks!!! These look soo good!

  27. [...] The recipe is available click here. [...]

  28. Kellie says:

    These are so good!! I made them today but used my own sugar cookie recipe in place of the Pillsbury dough. Delicious! My whole family has declared that they are the best cookies they’ve had. Thanks for the great idea! :)

  29. Deb says:

    I want to Ke these for a wedding so can you freeze them? Have many cookies do you get from a recipe?

  30. Deb says:

    I want to mKe these for a wedding so can you freeze them? Have many cookies do you get from a recipe?

  31. Diane says:

    Amy – I agree with everyone else that these look fantastic. The buttery, cinnamony topping, sigh. If I wasn’t already committed to a cake for Texasman today, these would be up. I do have one question: I store my recipes as Word documents. This lets me take out some of the “how to make” pictures I might not want or need, yet keep a couple of pictures of the finished product for inspiration. I am usually able to do this with the simple “highlight, copy, paste” technique. I can’t do that with this recipe. I downloaded the PDF file, then saved it as a text file – but that took away all the pictures and made the formatting strange. I saved the recipe as a PDF, which left the pretty pictures, but gave me 16 pages for the recipe. I don’t know if this is something you can adjust or not – or if there’s a reason you don’t want to allow this option – but surely I can’t be the only one who uses this easy technique to save recipes. Thanks for taking the time to read this and maybe changing how your site works for sharing your recipes. Thanks again, Diane

  32. Diane says:

    Amy – I tried again, just for the heck of it – and this time I was able to “copy and paste.” So clearly I have tumbled over that invisible edge where sanity and insanity meet. Please just delete my last message – except for the compliment!, and accept my apology for disturbing your much more important work of developing and baking these incredible recipes. Once again, thanks and my apology. Diane

  33. chelsee says:

    so i am curious, can i use regular milk rather than buttermilk? i literally have no idea where to find buttermilk. lol. anything i can use as a substitute? i heard you can use like, milk & vinegar or something.? lol
    thanks for this recipe! i looove cookies and i am so excited to see something related to coffee cake that DOESNT have RAISINS or NUTS! I HATE when cookies/cakes/breads have raisins or nuts!!!! lol

  34. chelsee says:

    oh oops i commented on the wrong thing! there is no buttermilk in this recipe!! lmao im so dumb. sorry i was just recently reading another recipe that had buttermilk in it and accidentally posted it here. either way these look so yummy!

  35. Jody says:

    made these delectable gems (but used the sugar-doodle vanilla cookie recipe with gluten free flour) my new FAVORITE cookie!!!

  36. [...] Look at the heavenly toppings, cinnamon crumble and glazed sugar…promise bunch of sweetness! Both make a distinct impact on the appearance and flavor of this cookie! I don’t need to put sugar on my coffee anymore, I have lots of them from my cookies! Oh, this make me think about one cozy morning with my husband together with coffee and these yummy cookies! If you like to make perfect Coffee Cake Cookie, browse over the source. [...]

  37. [...] Go check out her blog! [...]

  38. Grace Gaige says:

    I am planning on making these for my woman’s group on Tues. night. I was wondering though how they would taste using choc. chip cookie dough instead of the sugar cookie dough. Guess that will be my next project to try after making the original recipe.

  39. Samantha says:

    You are my new favorite person. These are AMAZING!

Leave a Reply